As English rises, should we fear for the Dutch language?
The Dutch Language Union has commissioned a study to find out the state of the language – and though English may be everywhere in Flanders, it’s not necessarily something to worry about
Mind our language
Johan De Caluwe’s answer to people with such existential language fears: Relax, Dutch is doing just fine.
And he’s got the data to back it up. With a handful of colleagues at the Meertens Institute in the Netherlands, De Caluwe, a professor of Dutch linguistics at Ghent University, oversaw a large-scale study that explored the state of Dutch in Flanders and the Netherlands, the first of its kind.
The study found no evidence to suggest that Dutch – spoken by 24 million people around the world and the eighth biggest language in the European Union by number of native speakers – is at risk of disappearing any time soon.
“Dutch is by no means a language under threat. Dutch is assured of a future as long as so many people in Flanders continue to pass on the language to their children,” he says, noting that children born today have a life expectancy of 90 to 100 years. “So if the language dies out, that’s not something we will experience; it will be for the generation after us.”
A real worry?
The expansive study was commissioned by the Dutch Language Union, the organisation that defends the interests of Dutch-speakers by serving as knowledge centre, think tank and policy institute, and it will be repeated every two years.
It was launched in response to the worries of ordinary citizens in Flanders and the Netherlands, De Caluwe explains, noting that the Dutch Language Union regularly received complaints and letters from Dutch-speakers genuinely worried about the future of Dutch in an increasingly global world that has adopted English as its common language.
What’s important for me, and for the Dutch Language Union, are the interests of language users; that they are able to do everything they want in that language
“There’s a real worry, and it’s increasing,” he says. “I think everyone felt that research was needed.” The study surveyed some 6,000 people in Flanders and the Netherlands on the social settings in which they choose to speak Dutch, and those in which they choose to speak, for instance, English, Italian or Arabic – from ordering takeaway food to commenting on a Facebook thread.
The study found that Dutch continues to be the main language in all the domains surveyed but that it is facing strong competition from, and sometimes even being displaced by, English in four areas: internet and social media, academic publishing, university education and popular music.
According to figures from the union, 22% of master’s degrees in Flanders are currently taught in a language that’s not Dutch, and usually that language is English (separate figures for English do not exist). In the Netherlands, that figure is 66%.
The preference for English in higher education is having a ripple effect, with some primary schools now offering English as a separate subject – traditionally taught only in secondary school – or teaching subjects like history or geography in English.
De Caluwe isn’t against such developments. But, he warns: “This is a domain where I think public discussion is needed – to what extent do we want to go along with this bilingualism? Because I think that is something that’s moving closer, an increasingly broader Dutch-English bilingualism.”
For a professor in Dutch linguistics, De Caluwe is coolly pragmatic about the importance of the language. “I don’t have an unconditional attachment to Dutch,” he says. “What’s important for me, and for the Dutch Language Union, are the interests of language users; that they are able to do everything they want to in that language,” he says. For instance, accessing Dutch-language texts on a particular topic, or being able to read user manuals and medicine package inserts.
“We have to ensure that everyone has access to information in the language they know best,” he says. “But, if over time, it just so happens that everyone also has a good level of English, as far as I’m concerned, we could do a lot of things in English.”
Photo: One in five master’s degrees in Flanders is currently taught in a language other than Dutch and the preference for English is having a ripple effect
© Nicolas Maeterlinck/Belga